An excerpt from a book I’m reading by Amanda Marcotte, “IT’S A JUNGLE OUT THERE: THE FEMINIST SURVIVAL GUIDE TO POLITICALLY INHOSPITABLE ENVIRONMENTS.”
MEN WHO THINK YOU’RE A CHALLENGE
Despite the stereotype that romantic comedies are ruinous solely to women’s expectations, the truth of the matter is there are a lot of men out there who have some pretty cracked opinions on what’s hot and sexy, opinions that seem to come directly from romantic comedies. One of the most irritating of these is the idea that nothing is more romantic than taming the wild filly. We’ve all seen this plot in movies- the headstrong, intellectual young woman brought to her senses by the firm guidance of a tough young stud. It’s all fun and games until you’re a feminist, which is translated as “wild filly who needs taming” in romantic comedy terms. Which means that you’re going to find yourself in many situations where men have absorbed the lessons of The Philadelphia Story and all its sequels, and are going to try to woo you by taking you down a few notches. So, some strategies on fighting them off.
FIRST, LEARN TO SPOT THEM
Sometimes this isn’t hard. My all-time favorite story of someone trying to hit on me with the “fight with them, they love that” strategy involves the guy who caught me drinking a Miller Lite, bought me some mircobrew, came over, and said, “I bought that for you so you can learn to drink real beer.” However, not all of them are that easy to spot right off the bat, since most have learned to have little more subterfuge. The rule of thumb is that a guy is enamored of you-as-a-challenge if he seems to think that your habits, tastes, or intellectual pursuits exists only to be analyzed and possibly corrected by men. Mix in the fact that he will be oblivious to hints to buzz off and you’ll know you’ve managed to attract someone who thinks you’re a challenge.
For instance, these guys are drawn like flies to women who are reading or writing in public. While it’s quite likely true that some women do read or write in public in an attempt to attract men, some of us honestly do have a reason not to be sequestered in the house to read or write. The thinks-you’re-a-challenge guy will interrupt you to ask what you’re reading or writing, but more importantly, he’ll be aggressive in questioning you about it. (I can’t blame a decent guy simply looking for an opening, but they tend to be doing just that and nothing more.) To diagnose if he’s that kind of guy, I tend to just flash the title of the book at him or answer rather curtly. If he asks a bunch of leading, nosy questions about what it is-”So, you’re a big feminist, then?” being the most obnoxious-it’s time to run him off. However, as above beer example shows, some guys-who-think-you’re-a-challenge will seek anything to be aggressive about.
WHAT NOT TO DO TO GET RID OF HIM
The number one thing about these guy is that they can’t take no for an answer. “No” is a challenge, and remember, they think they want a challenge. “No” will eventually work, if you are very repetitive and show no other signs of life besides the word “no.” That can be time-consuming and irritating, though. Trying to escalate the strength of the rejection can make it even worse. Whatever you do, don’t try to be clever and say, “Oh, I get it. You’re going to tame the wild, overintellectualized feminist beast. Good luck with that.” Yes, it’s funny, but it’s also exactly what the female lead in a romantic comedy would say, and will probably only encourage him.
STRATEGY ONE TO RUN HIM OFF
The key is that these guys only think they want a challenge. What they want is someone who will offer token resistance and then fall into their arms, having learned the danger of their wicked feminist ways. As such, the Chatty Cathy routine works pretty well to run them off. When a guy starts the aggressive questioning, use that as your excuse to run your mouth, not letting him get word in edgewise, going over every detail of your intellectual world in great detail. If he can’t get a word edgewise, he can’t live out his fantasy and will run away soon enough. A good preventive strategy is to be obnoxiously feminist too. Don’t just read or tap away on your laptop in public. Do so with an Andrea Dworkin book sitting title-up next to you and a NOW sweatshirt on. Go way over their heads. This might also work as a good filter, since you know anyone who’ll chat you up if you look like that doesn’t want to change a damn thing about you.
STRATEGY TWO TO RUN HIM OFF
Just don’t be a challenge at all. This one might be a little harder to pull off, because it takes a certain Zen lack of ego, but it can work. Every challenging question he asks, simply agree with whatever he’s saying and refuse to elaborate. “You’re right.” Yeah, probably.” “I’m sure whatever you’re saying is true, I wouldn’t know.” No static, no electricity, nothing to keep him motivated. Much, much harder to pull off than the first one, but it can be amusing if you’re good at it.
WHEN YOU WONT JUST GET CANCER AND DIE
My working theory is that romantic comedies are the work of Satan, and not the good Satan. For one thing, they are universally disdained as “chick flicks,” and yet somehow a great number of men absorb the message of the two odious romantic comedy cliches. The first is the headstrong woman who is tamed by The Cock, as previously mentioned. In these flicks, the woman’s headstrongness is shown as brittle, career-oriented, and unromantic about sex. And that’s bad enough, but there’s an even worse stereotype of the headstrong woman lurking in the annals of romantic-comedy-cum-melodrama, and that’s the flighty but headstrong eccentric who teaches the hero a thing of two about life before exiting stage right, often due to some sort of disease. She has to die or leave somehow, because audiences are incapable of picturing the heroine as a wife, since wives are supposed to be submissive and competent.
For what it’s worth, the best antidote to this cliche is probably Sofia Coppola’s movie The Virgin Suicides, where the eccentric, exotic female lead kills her own damn self, leaving the viewer with the uncomfortable impression that being an exotic fantasy who must somehow exit stage right after forever changing some impressionable young man isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.
My field research for his guide (i.e., asking my feminist friends) indicates that many feminists find that this particular romantic comedy cliche gives them real problems in real life. Many a young man will fall for the headstrong feminist, on the theory that she’s the quirky gal who will change his life forever. And then where reality sets in and it turns out that she’s not likely to develop leukemia anytime soon, things fall apart. There’s not much in the way of advice on how to handle that, since those situations tend to self-terminate, but you can jazz it up a little.
FAKE YOUR DEATH
GIve him the movie. Consider it a romantic parting gift.
IF HE DUMPS YOU FIRST, ACT REALLY RELIEVED
He wont see it coming, which is death to the movie-trained mentality. If you have trouble feeling relieved, think about how funny it will be when he realizes that you’re not going to sob and sob over him, and that might help.
DUMP HIM FIRST AND TELL HIM YOU’RE DATING A REAL BRUISER NAMED HARLEY
Warning: While this is really funny, if you do this, you will be helping create a Nice Guy, a concept I’ll describe in detal later.
TELL HIM TO SAVE THE WORLD
One wrinkle in the whole thing is the lighter version of this cliche, which is the Superhero’s Girlfriend. You know the cliche. Superman, Spiderman-they fall in love with headstrong, quirky, awesome, and for once competent women. But you will never see the headstrong girlfriend actually marry the superhero and scare the audience with the idea of a bona fide wife having a mind of her own. Your soon-to-be ex, however, is not a superhero and so cant really give you the speech about how he loves you but alas, he doesn’t want to put you in danger by dating you. So, you could, if you wanted to, tell him that you love him but you’re holding him back from saving the world. He knows the cliche and may just eat it up.
TELL HIM YOU HAVE TO SAVE THE WORLD
Just recite the Superhero’s speech to him and blow his mind. It’s not supposed to work that way; women aren’t the ones who are supposed to degrudgingly give up True Love for duty. True Love is supposed to be their duty.
While he sits there with his mind blown, run away. Don’t forget, while fleeing the premises, to leave a sign on his door warning other women that he’s been ruined by films were the heroine up and dies, leaving the hero to face the world stronger for having known her and unweakened for having paid attention to her.
-femme for thought